Evanescence: "I was fired for no good reason"

Despite reports last week of an amicable split between Evanescence guitarist John LeCompt and the chart-topping goth rockers, LeCompt has hit out at his former bandmates stating that "I was fired for no good reason."

According to a post on Lecompt's online blog, the guitarist said he didn't leave the band to spend more time with his family, but was actually fired by vocalist/founding member Amy Lee, over the phone, just two days before the singer married her therapist fiance Josh Hartzler:

"This call wasn't from a friend who appreciated me but from an enemy who was prepared to hurt me and my family," he says. "Without any warning or negotiations for my future, I was fired for no good reason. We have not always seen eye to eye on everything, but who does? Our common goal was always the same: To make Evanescence the best rock band it could ever be. I have always given blood, sweat and tears to make that happen but apparently that is not enough. I have now become just another of the people fallen by the wayside on the revolving door of her life."

Drummer Rocky Gray, who also reportedly left the band left the band, hinted through his own online blog that he may have been fired too.

"Amy Lee's management e-mailed me last night to tell me that, in their view, the contract I signed to record, perform and tour with the group says that I'm not allowed to have any free speech in regard to Evanescence," he says. "The way they spin it, I'm not even allowed to say I quit the group, I guess. But the news is out there, so, there ya go. I need to have a lawyer read over all that mess to tell me what, when and how I can tell you all - the REAL fans - what really went down, if I ever can, haha."


Posted by Dan at 10:54AM | May 14, 2007
evanescence

evanescne are poop, amy lee cant sing. Hayley Williams is the best female vocals and paramore rock!

Posted by coleeeeeeeeee | May 14, 2007 11:40 AM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
evanescence

paramore r poo n hayley williams smells like a rotten fish cake!!!!

Posted by gemrawr | May 14, 2007 12:11 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
evanescence

errrrrrrr hello yes haylie can sing do u have ears?

Posted by carmen | May 14, 2007 12:40 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
evanescence

hayley cannot sing and when she duz it sounds like sum1 strangleing a cat on weed!!!! soooo yeh swivle!!! xxxx

Posted by Gemrawr | May 14, 2007 2:50 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
evanescence

i love both paramore and ev god u can like both hayley couldnt believe shed been voted prettiest along with amy lee its not limited choice

Posted by alexmcrev | April 9, 2008 8:14 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescence

WEll, for one, anyone saying that Hayley Williams is a better singer than Amy Lee has deffinatey lost the use of their ears. No disrespect to any of you who like Paramore, [I like about 1 song of theirs] but I do believe that Amy Lee has got such a better voice than Hayley. And as for the band splitting, I do not believe any of it. Amy Lee has got a beautiful voice, and has stated herself that the band is FAR from over. It even says that in her statement on the evanescence website. Amy Lee has been with the band ever since she was around 14 and I believe she would not let it fall apart now. She and the band have been through so much, and just like many other great bands, people join and move on, but the band keep on going. I have faith in Amy Lee and am 100% behind the band.

Posted by Belle | May 14, 2007 1:00 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescence

I totally don't believe that their splitting they're such a good band and have been together so long.

Posted by Sazzy | May 15, 2007 2:19 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
evanescence

well it looks like thats the end for them, i mean after reading what the 'fired' members have said then nobody else is guna want to fill in there shoes with an unexpected, unsecure future are they. ive never really liked evanessence but lets have it right you dont just end some bodys contract in a pretty sucessfull group over the phone or via email? it just dosent happen, thats neither fair or proffessional, but hey if thats how she wants to play it..
it seems to me like amy lee has just thought 'screw this i want a new band' and is slowly kicking everybody out...
funny, she always seemd so nice aswell

Posted by Livingdeadgirl | May 14, 2007 1:14 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
evanescence

its probably for the best. there are a lot 0f young female vocalists breaking through at the moment , and the cracks are showing that evanescence were nevr going to be in it for the long run. the last album showed this with her constant ramblings about herself nobody they have left.

Posted by ans | May 14, 2007 2:36 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
evanescence

its probably for the best. there are a lot 0f young female vocalists breaking through at the moment , and the cracks are showing that evanescence were nevr going to be in it for the long run. the last album showed this with her constant ramblings about herself nobody they have left.

Posted by ans | May 14, 2007 2:36 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
evanescence

Amy Lee is the most AMAZING singer i have EVER heard! No matter what happens with the band i will ALWAYS be a true supporter of Amy, and i will always respect her opinions no matter what they may be!! Love you Amy!! Louise x x x

Posted by Louise hey | May 14, 2007 4:17 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
evanescence

How can someone say that amy lee hasnt got good vocals!
Iam completely and utterely gutted that they have split up,
they have been my favourite band for like 6 years. I love them and hope they carry on. Amy lee has such a powering and idolic voice.
Im crying im so upset.
Pleas amy lee try your best to carry on.

:(

Posted by Nicola | May 14, 2007 4:33 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
evanescence

Honestly, none of us will ever know what really happened and why they left, but i think amy is trying to do the best for the band and no one else has more right than her to decide about the future of evanescence... Amy, i haven't had the chance to see you live yet so please, stick around for as long as you can, congrats on your wedding:)

Posted by amy_superfan | June 18, 2007 11:52 AM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
evanescence

i'm a big fan of amy lee and evanescence i wuld be soooooo devastated if they broke up but i hope they don't

Posted by jay | May 14, 2007 7:27 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
evanescence

to be honest i don't know what thebig deal is Evanescence have their own thing and so do Paramore their both great bands and i don't know why you guys are fighting about it their both great Hayley Williams can sing and so can Amy Lee just get over it plez its geting pretty boring now! >:(

Posted by Tanya | May 15, 2007 1:43 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
evanescence

Fuk off. Amy Lee is an awsome singer. Much better than Hayley.

Posted by Sazzy | May 15, 2007 2:21 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
evanescence

I enjoyed listening to your music Evanescence, but without John and Rocky, Evanescence is nothin.

I also believe that Rocky you get to have his say in the band after all, his drumming was immense XD

Amy Lee, yesh she's pretteh and yeah she can sing but from the article i've just read she sounds like a stuck-up bitch who thinks she's more superior than the rest of Evanescence!

From Shizznit

I send my <3 to John and Rocky =]

Posted by Shizznit | May 18, 2007 5:31 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
evanescence

amy lee is te best singer, evanescence it's not over.... now with will and troy (temporally obviusly) they'll rock on'!!!! and maybe wil & troy stay in evanescence for a long time!!!!!!!!!!!
EVANESCENCE RULES!!!!!

Posted by venezuelaaaaaaaaaaaa | May 19, 2007 4:11 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
m497z

m780k

Posted by ro439ck | August 22, 2007 8:11 AM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
evanescence

youre kidding right i mean hayley cant sing i like the Riot cd only cos of wat shes singing about Amy lee is well better she CAN sing and ALL her songs mean something

Posted by Melissa | November 5, 2007 11:25 AM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
evanescence

u kidding amy lees vocals harmonize so well with any music
i love paramore too but hayley williams needs singing lessons

Posted by greenday gurl | January 2, 2008 6:19 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
evanescence

well i think you should fuck off and i would like to hear u sing like that u fucking twat and how are they pop u must be deaf y r u looking at this bit about evenescence if u dont like them so try fucking off

Posted by sarah | May 19, 2008 9:44 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
ABOUT TIME TOO!

Come on they were overrated and overpricing their albums. i would rather listen to Mozart than these excuses for musicians. i hope that they split but i wish Amy a long happy relationship with her pertner. good luck to all of you, you're gonna need it!

Posted by Bayzil | May 14, 2007 11:42 AM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
evanescence vs. within temptation

the amount of times i hear people saying within temptation copy evanescence is f***ing irritating. within temptation started WAY before evanescence ... it's evanescence who copy w.t - they need to get their own sound.

Posted by macabre | May 14, 2007 11:44 AM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
evanescence vs. within temptation

evanescence never copied WT besides even if they did (didnt) u ask people whether they like evanescence and WT or even heard of them majority well say Evanescence cos of bring me 2 life and call me when youre sober any1 name any POPULAR WT songs and any POPULAR evanescence songs

Posted by Melissa | November 5, 2007 11:33 AM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
bob

yeh bob xx

Posted by gemrawr | May 14, 2007 11:52 AM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
bob

yeh bob xx

Posted by gemrawr | May 14, 2007 11:53 AM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
bob

yeh bob xx

Posted by gemrawr | May 14, 2007 11:53 AM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
ur mum

bob ur soo sexy!! i love you!!

Posted by fann will | May 14, 2007 12:04 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
lol

yeh bob iz sexy!!!!! so iz chris lol

Posted by gemrawr | May 14, 2007 12:08 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   

Lolz.
It seems Amy Lee just doesn't like anyone!
She seems to always be the cause of friction/leaving band members.
Maybe (and this is a MAYBE, I don't know obviously) she's too arrogant to accept others' musical ideas.
She should just become a solo artist, I think.
Avoid all this stresss and shit.

Posted by Juliet | May 14, 2007 12:10 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescence "is it over"

Lets face it - Evanescence is basically Amy Lee and a group of men. Yes she is fit, she can sing and yes she does a great live show.
She could just go single like most female lead vocallist but could anyone actually care ??? i dont !

Posted by claire sullivan | May 14, 2007 12:11 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   

I think it is about time that the band started falling off the rails. They have never been any good, even at what they do let alone in comparison to the rocks gods or even up coming stars such as MCR.

This just shows how fame has gone to Amy's head. Now its time for them to move over and for a real band to take over the airwaves.

Posted by Matt Duchezeau | May 14, 2007 12:11 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
poo

MCR R SHIT !!!! EMO FAGS!!!!! GO HOME

Posted by gemRawr | May 14, 2007 12:13 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
poo

dood don't doubt MCR, there better than u will evah b u fuckin fag!!

Posted by this dood | May 14, 2007 5:40 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Personally

I think Amy Lee's let the fame go to her head.
She's become really full of herself, or thats what it seems like to me.

Evanescence, to me, don't seem like anything too exciting, and they're just really overrated.
Mayeb something like this happening with bring Amy Lee back down to earth!

Posted by Emz | May 14, 2007 12:12 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
evanescence

are not that good
so im not really fussed of this is the last of them
i dont seen why its all about amy lee when its a band
they were probably fired so they got more attention and then amy lee will get all the attention once again.
MCR are awesome :)
screw you MCR haters :]
Steph Way-Bryar x

Posted by Steph Way-Bryar | May 14, 2007 12:13 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
evanescence

fuck you mcr lovers!!!!

Posted by gemrawr | May 14, 2007 12:19 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   

iiiii eat pooo!!

Posted by hehehehe! | May 14, 2007 2:37 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
evanescence

Gutted that John and Rocky have left. Happens to every band in the end. Not so sure about MCR being around for long either! Mikey away and frank following next spring, the cracks are showing!

Posted by stu | May 16, 2007 2:55 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescence

OMG! Evanescence are just the greatest band about, they can't split up they just can't. They have introduced me to the world goth rock and can't imagine life without them. I hoe things all work out ok....

Posted by sasha | May 14, 2007 12:14 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescence

I think that Evanescence were going off a bit a long time ago. The loss of key members after the first album didn't bode well for them. It made them basically Amy Lee and support which isn't how any band should work.

It would seem it is the beginning of the end for Evanescence. And to be honest, It has been a long time coming.

Posted by Amanda | May 14, 2007 12:15 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Of course it's not over!

As long as there is Amy lee there will be Evanescence; I never knew anything about the first guy leaving before this album was released. All I noticed was that they were FINALLY releasing a new album and it was still classic Evanescence but more grown up. They WILL survive this.
And no one's copying anyone; the bands that sound similar don't hate eachother as a result so why should the fans?

Posted by Lady Kat | May 14, 2007 12:15 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
evanescence

Lets see they aren't all that good but they aren't all that bad either, i dont think they will be missed, but i think alot of people including myself will be waiting in shear horror of what may come next be it solo careers or side projects. Evanescence have had their day and lets be honest it wasn't a good one was it?

Posted by vincent evans | May 14, 2007 12:15 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescence

I have always liked Evanescence. And their songs. But never actually the band. Yea, Amy Lee is pretty and really talented but I have never liked her and I believe John LeCompt when he says he was fired by Amy Lee. She seems really cold to me. There's no need to wonder why her old band members walked off stage leaving her there. She deserves. She always complains about her life in her songs, and yes, they do make good songs and people can relate to them. But seriously couldn't she write some happy songs? Surely her life hasn't been all bad. This rock chick needs to get over herself and start being nice to her band members before her fame and fortune are snatched away from her.

Link to MySpace: www.myspace.com/amaherst

Posted by Mel | May 14, 2007 12:16 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescence

I completely agree! I always thought before she would be alright and stuff, but over time I've heard things about her being cold...she is talented like you say, but she's gonna lose it all if she doesn't give some respect to the people that helped get her there...her band members!! You seriously hit the nail on the head, there is no better way of exlpaining it than that - well done!

Posted by Dante | May 16, 2007 3:45 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
who cares?

this LeCompt guy is clearly just doing it for a bit of fame/publicity. because, lets face it, evanescense is just Amy Lee's band, barely anyone knows the rest of the band, nor do they give a shit. I mean, doesn't it all sound like a bit of a familiar story from other ex-band members. the bassist from panic! at the disco, the bassist from the darkness...and countless others. Its the same bullshit we get everytime a member leaves or gets kicked out. So me thinks its because no one recognises them or their names, and they want some recognition. (well we all recognise the ex-darkness guy for his magnificent tash, but apart from that...) it all sounds like a cliched backlash.

hopefully it will all end, and not give people a reason to have to run away from the main stage at download ahahaha.

Posted by chris deeks | May 14, 2007 12:16 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
evanescence

i think amy lee has the potential to go on with any musicians as long as she connects with them and doesnt just get people in for the sec of it.. people say they are like within temptation but how many bands are alike. its like arguing over blind melon and pearl jam both grunge bands.. gothic female vocalists are pretty similar it doesnt matter who came out first its who has the better voice and i personally believe amy is great i think she waivered a bit on the last album but she can get it back and show everyone what shes really made of!

Posted by kate kinder | May 14, 2007 12:17 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   

Amy Lee is a stuck up cow.
She's just trying to glorify herself.
Sharon Den Adel is much better.

Posted by Scoot | May 14, 2007 12:17 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
ok..

To be honest, I couldn't give a crap if they quit or if they were fired. At the end of the day, they're not in the band anymore. What makes them think we actually care? (exept for the die hard Evanescence fans, of course!) But theres probably about 3 of them anyway, right?
I think we should get Brody Dalle (from The Distillers) to beat the crap out of Amy Lee, she looks like she needs it...

Posted by Becki | May 14, 2007 12:18 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
fucking hell.

yet another fucking awesome band down the shitter.
this is yet another upset for devout Evanescence fans like myself.
to hear about this, is pretty shit.

a voice like amy lee's is one of rarity,
although people seem to believe that she has NO originality & is copying within temptation, who are also awesome.
honestly, if you believe that, you MUST be high or something,
CLEARLY amy lee's voice & sharon den adel's voice differentiate.

the band in general have made an impact on my taste in music. such music of heaviness & emotion, with a lead singer witht the voice of an angel, what more could you want?

if they break up, i think i would resort to becoming an emo [lol]

Posted by Nay | May 14, 2007 12:19 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
fucking hell.

nooooo dnt do it my fellow metal heads!!! dont give in too the emo nesss stay with the good music aka evanescence, slipknot cradle of filth fear factoey metalica. xxxx

Posted by gemrawr | May 14, 2007 12:25 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Not The Boss!

Just because she's the face of Evanescence, doesn't make Amy Lee the boss. Sure, she's good looking and has a great singing voice, but without the rest of the band behind her, she's nothing. Amy needs to rethink her life if she thinks she can do shit like this whenever and to whoever she wants.

Posted by G.J.V. | May 14, 2007 12:20 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanecense

Personally i thought they wehere over a long time ago !
The second album was not as satisfyin as the first i thot they dies with that album n i think they will never re live those moments again!

Posted by Sarah Jane White | May 14, 2007 12:21 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   

As long as there is Amy there is Evansescence.If that's her choice,I support.

Posted by Vesna | May 14, 2007 12:22 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
evanescence

i think that amy seems to give tghe vibe that she 'owns' evanescence, and therefore forming a new band under the same name would'nt be a problem for her, even though she is the only lasting original member. i think that rocky and john are absolutely great, and she made a BIG mistake in pushing them out of the band. but i think evanescence will go on without them...at least for a little while anyway.

Posted by cheryl | May 14, 2007 12:22 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evenescence will fight bk

they aint a band which will give up so easy.......i know they will bounce bk with a fight.......jus give them time to sort out their issues!!

Posted by Liam Moxon | May 14, 2007 12:22 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescence

They were over after their first CD, when everyone found some new faddy band to arse rape. People like Amy Lee just end up BEING the "band"; the actual musicians are just her backing, and to be honest, they could go and be in their own band and do a hell of a lot better - maybe their talents would actually be recognised.

Yeah, Amy Lee annoys me.

Posted by Chronic. Aka Bob. Aka Nat. | May 14, 2007 12:23 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
buhbyee evanescence.

sure here piano stuff was good, but shit, if she does a whole album of just her wailing on about how her life sucks but it'll be ok because she has her piano, i don't think i'll be buying the next album.
she should get over herself, because to be quite honest, she aint nothing but a pretty face,

Posted by rachael | May 14, 2007 12:25 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanesence

Yaaaaaaaaaaaaay!!! Good riddance, they suck!

Posted by Philly Gumbo | May 14, 2007 12:25 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescence


So she may have a pretty face BUT sounds like she has no heart!! There is justice in the world..... So does this mean they wont be at download now??? please say they are pulling out and replace them with Lacuna Coil or within temptation, oh PLEASE!!!

Posted by Nicola Prebble | May 14, 2007 12:25 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   

All I can say is that over the last few years Amy Lee has got so far up her own arse you cant see her head anymore. When I last spoke to her ex Shaun Morgan of Seether he told me that she'd dumped him "because her therapist told her to." Now she's married her therapist? Random! Plus she sued her old manager & claimed he raped & battered her. Now she's firing her band mates? Is there anyone Amy Lee wont fuck over?!

Posted by Toni G | May 14, 2007 12:25 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescence - The Revolving Door

Evanescence will be fine. When Ben Moody left, I'm sure Amy was thrilled that she was finally able to take much more control over the band. Over the recording of the last album, Will Boyd (SP?)[Bassist] left as well, and it seems to me that Amy has now put the final nail in the coffin, burying Evanescence as a band, and making it a one-woman show. Or, like the reason Slash left Guns N' Roses, Amy has pretty much become a musical dictator

I think they'll be another Evanescence album, but it'll be Amy dictating what notes the rest of the band should play. I believe she will be the only person allowed to have crative input over the music, and if anyone tries to stand in her way of that, they'll go down the same root as John LeCompt

When Ben left the band, I thought it was a diva strop on his behalf, because Amy was in the limelight, and he wasn't receiving as much credit for his work on Fallen. But now, I'm not too sure. It sounds like Amy is difficult to work with, and the evidence is in that fact they can't keep the same line-up for more than 3 singles

Posted by Mark Mason | May 14, 2007 12:27 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
holy jizz...

at the end of the day... if evanescence breaks up, its not going to hamper amy lee's career in any way.
no offense to the other members but amy was the face of E. and she can do whats shes good at without them, for instance when she dueted with seether it was a relatively gd song.
she doesn't need them, because its the voice that brings the audience's the shows.
all you goth boys can cry that this is untrue. but it is.
however not in enter shikari's case... everything about them makes a lump in my trousers.
but yeah, thats all i have to say.

like you.
will you be my friend?

Posted by kyle | May 14, 2007 12:27 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   

I doubt its all over, they have gone thought this before, people leaving is a normal thing for a band. (thats unstable to say the least)
There is a 50-50 chance they will rise past it.

Posted by vicki | May 14, 2007 12:28 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
and...

Can you really tell the difference between Amy Lee's arse and head these days? I mean, whatever sound comes out of her from either way sounds exactly the same to me!

Posted by Becki | May 14, 2007 12:28 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescence

So, two members of Evanescence have been fired now? Why doesn't Amy Lee just go fucking solo and get done with it! Sounds like thats what she wants.

Posted by Daniel Rigg | May 14, 2007 12:29 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
So...

Personally i think That Evanesence Has gone on too long. When their fist album came out it was good. It was slightly different. But Amy Lee has been so Far up her own arse! Yeah she's Pretty & she can sing but no-one cares anymore. There are just too many bands now-a-days like them...Christ. We need something different.

Posted by Emma | May 14, 2007 12:30 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Is it all over for Evanscence?

Is it all over for Evanescence? Is it bollocks. The only person the little kids care about in Evanesence is Amy Lee. To them, Evanescence IS Amy Lee. The rest of the members could change every gig and I bet most of the little kid fans wouldn't know or care.

Posted by Matt Bradley | May 14, 2007 12:30 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
it was kind of innevitable

it does seem that fame and all that has gone ot Amy Lee's head, its like evanescence is just all about her, you can see that in videos, interviews, everywhere. she needs to realise that she cant just drop whoever she wants whenever she wants like that, or one day she is going to end up dropped.
i really hope they dont split up completely because i've never had the chance to see them live yet. i think they can come through this though, because they came through the split with Ben Moody.

Posted by Lyndsey | May 14, 2007 12:31 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Devastated

I am absolutely devastated that Evanescence is going down! i am totally in love with Amy Lee and EV Rule!

There music has totally inspired me and helped me pick myself up from the lowest points of my life!!

I cant believe that this may be the end for EV!
Amy is such an awesome women and has a voice that is totally unique and unbeatable!
I hope she wont disappear from the music scene for good!!

Posted by Helen | May 14, 2007 12:33 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescence

the spark for them was gone long ago this was just time catching up


www.myspace.com/captain_bubble_beard

Posted by zertos | May 14, 2007 12:34 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evawhatever

I always thought I was an Evanescence fan. I'd buy their albums, DVDs, go to their gigs but all this news lately has confused me. I really don't seem to care.

I doubt we'll ever really know what happened with the whole 'did they quit or did they get sacked' business. I will be interested to see if they do carry on though, they have said they'll honour all their gig and festival comitments but I really can't see that happening. And if they do what the hell kind of reception will they get? I can imagine some hardcore Ev fans being very pissed off with all this.

Oh well, I'm still semi-mad at them for cancelling their Manchester gig last year just becuase John's wife went into labour. Tell me, does it really need all of Evanescence to fly back to the US becuase she went into labour? Were they delivering the baby or something? I don't think so.

Posted by Sarah Lenaerts | May 14, 2007 12:34 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescence

well amy lee can sing and with the exit of the Drummer and Guitarist all i think is they need to start looking for replacements sooner rather than later if they wanna keep going. would offer my guitaring skills myself but not quite that good as of yet ha-ha

check bk with you all laters

Reaper

Posted by Reaper | May 14, 2007 12:34 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Like it'll matter

They'll carry on regardless; when Ben Moody - supposedly the songwriting brains behind the band - left, they didn't exactly and pack up and go home.

It's all very dramatic, but as even the best of bands have proven, revolving line-ups can sometimes do little to hamper a band's success. Though I wouldn't be lumping Evanescence with the 'best of bands' any time soon.

Posted by Pags | May 14, 2007 12:34 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   

After hearing their latest album i wasn't best impressed...hey were lacking the talent they had on their previous albums. I think it's about time Amy went it alone, because to be honest...apart from die-hard fans...who actually knew the names of the instrumentalists? Everyone knows Evanesence for Amy Lee...she could go far on her own and it's about time she realised this and went for it.

Her voice is amazing, and she is a talented pianist...so why not give it a go with just this instead of making her way through guitarists and drummers...at least that way there would be no-one to fire but herself!

Posted by Bex | May 14, 2007 12:38 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
And?

Amy must have a logical reason for firing her former band members. Even if we can't see ANY reason to ditch them, she must have thought it through somewhere. I don't think she would have gone out deliberately to hurt either of their feelings. Obviously, it did, but hey, thats life. Shit happens. I think Evanescence are a great band, but things like this do happen.
And I don't think they'll split either. They've been through this sort of thing before, and they've got through it.
And on a lighter note, all the best to Amy and Josh.

Posted by Chelleh | May 14, 2007 12:38 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Holy poop shatman!

This sounds really out of line for Amy Lee.
I can't really see her being such a over-powering bitch.
Well, only in my fantasies, but nows not the time.

I will be utterly gutted if they break up.
Seen as it's so close to Download aswell.

Saying that, if Amy were to spawn a solo career.
I doubt she would be able to break the Evanescence sound.

If it all goes tits up, she could always do porn :]

Posted by Callam Hopkins | May 14, 2007 12:39 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
This just confirms

what I've thought for a long time, at least since Ben's departure, that Ev is not so much a band than Amy Lee and hired goons who can be disposed of as soon as they dare to "compromise her vision" or somesuch crap.

Shame, as I loved the first album but then there's been a lot of ego expansion sice then...

Posted by Gargoyle | May 14, 2007 12:39 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescence: Is it all over?

I have always been a big fan of evanescence and I still adore Fallen. But with all the trouble you read about nowadays, with Amy Lee and members coming and going, even i'm starting to think its time they called it a day. The new album to me feels like all the important stuff, like the music, has been lost behind Amy and her public relations.
It's like watching what I used think were a great band become a huge commercial train wreck.

Posted by Jemma | May 14, 2007 12:40 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescence

Geeze, smart move to kick both the drummer and the guitarist out, weeks before the festival season starts.
I hope it's the end of them, cuz in my eyes the music kept on getting worse.

Posted by Dana | May 14, 2007 12:40 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescence

Evanescence fucking rock! I think it's just better if Amy Lee goes solo, then she wont have to worry about band members.

Posted by A. Watson | May 14, 2007 12:40 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Over? Yes ;)

Well, honestly...I don't care if everything's over with Evanesence or not, I never liked them, Amy Laa can't sing (in fact, her voice makes my ears ache), the songs are cheap and without any kind of soul or at least personal style... It's grand for all human beings that they might quit...

Posted by Zara | May 14, 2007 12:41 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Over? Yes ;)

Amy Lee I meant^^ Sorry about that x)

Posted by Zara | May 14, 2007 12:42 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
NO!!!!

NO! Evanesecence can't be over!!!
:'(
Amy Lee is the sexiest woman ever!!!

Posted by Becky Logan | May 14, 2007 12:42 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
What's going on!

I really do not know why these talented musicians would leave a band that they have worked so hard for and with great success. I think that there has to be something else going on behind the scenes. I have always loved evanescence and when ben moody left i was like nooooooo, but they moved on from there so i think that they will move on again from this. I was shocked that John and Rocky left, i think we need to know why. Ro!x

Posted by Rolo | May 14, 2007 12:42 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Amy Lee, get over yourself!

Fired two days after she got married? Sounds like the husband was jealous in my opinion.
Why couldn't Amy Lee just leave things as they were? She dictates everything about that band, for god sake, the band weren't even on the cover of the new album, only Amy Lee was, and in K! interviews she's always the one on the cover and the one answering the questions! It's like she's a solo artist and they're the backing band. I used to like Evanescence, that was before I started seeing Amy Lee's face everywhere with quotes like "Oh I saw that album as a cry for help" For god sake woman it wasn't only you who made it, give the others some credit why don't you and stop looking for sympathy because it seems to me you have a pretty awesome life, but if you don't like it why don't you just get therapy? Like every other ego-maniac looking for attention.
So now I couldn't care less if they split up, the band's only staying alive to feed Amy Lee's ego and that's not a good thing, so let it die!

Posted by MeganMURDER | May 14, 2007 12:43 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Outrageous!

I can't believe it. I admit Evanesence weren't as good as they were with the album "Fallen" but at the end of the day, Evanesence are a great band and Amy Lee is just fantastic! I can't see them splitting up completely....

Posted by Krissy Quinton | May 14, 2007 12:43 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
is it all over

I bludy hope so thye have turned so crap she cnt sing anymre and wen she dus its terrible they have like 1 gud song ever which is Bring me to life, WHICH isnt that good i say stop playing popy music on kerrang n stat playin good love metal HIM

Posted by jordi | May 14, 2007 12:45 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   

the changeover/replacal of the rest of the band is amys way of trying to fix a problem that still remains, which is her, she knew the band was failing, but is too full of herself to realise that it was her doing.

I feel that they should just save face and just split up, and let the name Evanescence be remembered for the original and, not what has been brought in, Maybe amy will persue a solo career, guess then we'll find out if she was what was at fault, because if Evanescence failed, and she fails, who else is there left to blame?

niff

www.myspace.com/niff343

Posted by niff | May 14, 2007 12:45 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Lets face it

Evanescance was never a band.
It's Amy Lee and a couple of minions who likes to welcome into the Lee Camp then when she's bored, decide, screw you, you're fired.
At the end of the day, Evanescence is Amy Lee's baby and she'll keep her baby alive for as long as she possibly can, regardless of who she hurts in the process. I just hope that what has happened to John LeCompt and Rocky Gray is a warning to other professional musicians approached to join Evanescence.

Posted by Aidsy | May 14, 2007 12:45 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescence

ok, i DONT think Evanescence will split because there thousands of other great guitarists out there and thousands of amazing drummers aswell. I mean, its not as if they can say " oh we dont want anyone else in because no one is better than Rocky Grey, because there is always someone better than you....

Posted by Ben | May 14, 2007 12:45 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
evanescence

Its gotta be all over for evanesence now!! after the guy lead singer left a few years ago they started to go down hill but now they av to replace basically the whole band they av no chnace of comin back from it

Posted by Adam Noronha | May 14, 2007 12:46 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
They think it's all over... it is now!

C'mon lets admit it, two people leaving/being fired from the band is never a good sign. At the current album ''The Open Door'' was a huge let down for me. And Amy Lee is always in the spotlight, How many people can honestly say they know anything about the other members?

Posted by Sophie Barnett | May 14, 2007 12:47 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   

I really don't think there's anything to worry about to be honest. I did read that they were still coming to Download, and surely with an album better than Fallen now is not the time to call it quits is it?

Posted by Joel Watkins | May 14, 2007 12:50 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
been there, done that!

this is nothing new for evanescence.
they've fallen out and had break ups before their second album came out!

but did it affect them, no. not really. ok, the open door was a bit of a disapointment but it wasnt like they were a complete disaster!

something obviosuly wasnt working in the band and sometimes you've got to look after number 1.

however Amy Lee does seem to be a bit of a control freak and has probably been brain-washed by her therapist hubby! lol!

Posted by Adam | May 14, 2007 12:51 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   

But then again with Amy Lee recently married and not 1 but 2 members left the band you never know what will happen.

Posted by Joel Watkins | May 14, 2007 12:51 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescence

There is no way that they are breaking up. They will get replacements for John... i saw them last November and i personally thought that they were stronger than before if they do break up Amy Lee will find other means of success in the music industry and as long as they have fans turthefull fans they will live forever. Its just a hiccup like every band i.e Hawkwind endure this personally will make them a stronger band, i mean look at there come back since Ben Moody was fired they became the strong band writing music for Narnia (although it didn't get used).

Personally i think they will live for a long time. And fans who disagree with this then they are obviously not true fans. and should fuck off.

Much Love Luica <3

Posted by Lucia Murphy | May 14, 2007 12:52 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Would Amy Lee be better to go solo?

Well who knows what the truth really is.If that is the truth,then obviously the guys are better off without Amy Lee. She has an amazing voice and performs really well,but from what I'm hearing she doesnt have much of a heart. To make it into the music business and to have loyal fans,then you need to have a good heart.That's only my opinion.The band play great music and she's not going to find another drummer and guitarist that is better than Rocky and John.She is better to go and sing solo.She might not do as well,but I'm sure she'll still do great.After all,many of us would kill for a voice like hers.But not for her heart.

By Jenny Gardner

Posted by Jenny Gardner | May 14, 2007 12:56 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
evanescence

hmmmm just because they are leaving doesnt mean that the band will split up.
in fact it could be a good thing they can easily get new band members and start again.
every one knows who evanescence are so it wouldnt be difficult.
she has a good voice it would be a shame to waste it by just giving up and not carrying on.
it would be kind of pathetic anyway
more bands have gone through worse and they have carried on.
xXx <33 xXx

Posted by karina | May 14, 2007 1:00 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanes... what?

i've always thought evanescence was a product of the pop industry. Amy Lee pretends to be a very good song-writer, but everybody knows that she gets 3rd party people to do all that for her. She's only there to perform other person's songs. Regarding the band members being fired, it only proves what I say about the band being an industry product and not a real band, where members just dont "get fired".

Posted by Maria | May 14, 2007 1:02 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescence

So Evanescence might split? Evanescence is basically Amy Lee, she's pretty much what sums them up. I think they'd be able to continue after whats happened, afterall, it isn't the first time something like this has happened, and although I know jack-shit about the other band members, I think whatever has happened could have been handled better by ALL of them. Oviously there's more to it than what everyones letting on. Especially considering the members were fired so close to her wedding. I don't know, either way, I think Amy Lee needs a good slapping, it isn't anyway to treat people who helped make your last album so successful. So Evanescence might split? E

Posted by Tracey | May 14, 2007 1:02 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
All over

They aren't going to last through this. Their new album is nothing compared to Fallen when they had the talent of Ben Moody to write their songs. They've just turned into a band that want to please the crowd rather then write songs that mean something. I think this will be the final straw for them they've had so many members leave that nobody really knows who Evanescence really are anymore. There's too much focus on just Amy Lee as a person rather than the band itself. i think they should all go their seperate ways.

Posted by Aimee Gore | May 14, 2007 1:04 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
thank goth!

finally, Evanescence have finally hit a wall. iv hated that band ever since they came out. Bring me to life was only good because it featured a guest appearance from Paul McCoy from 12 stones [which is an awesome band that everyine should check out!]

they were so overated and yes, Amy Lee was rather hot and she could sing quite well but it was only ever about her!

her band were overshadowed by her. Every interview was with her, while most bands would include at least one other member!

i think that most other bands of this genre [ nightwish, lacuna coil, within temptation etc etc ] will fall into this problem at some point, tho lacuna coil does have the advantage that Christina Scabbia is just plain gorgreous end of argument!

Posted by Elliot Grimes | May 14, 2007 1:06 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Whoops!

It would appear I can't write properly! ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

Ignore the last sentance, it makes no sence. And eat squirrels.

Posted by Tracey | May 14, 2007 1:07 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
It's a shame..

I'll admit, I've never been a huge fan of Evanescence but a few of their songs have been stuck in my head in the past and their videos never seize to amaze me.
It's a real shame that this could be the end of the band.
Ever since Ben Moody left the band a few years back, it seems to have gone all down hill for them.
Amy Lee is such an amazing singer and she's absolutely stunning as well.
he whole band are increidbly talented and I'm sure we'll hear from them all very soon if Evanescence break up.
I wish each memeber all the best :]

Posted by Phi | May 14, 2007 1:07 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Finally...

Well, honestly?
It's about time! I'm sick of everyone saying that all female fronted bands are 'copying Evanescence'. Sure, Amy Lee has a strong & powerful voice, but she is Evanescence. You never hear about the rest of the band members ever, it's just her. She could easily replace all of her band members & still be as popular. It's just the way things are & I guess you can't really change it. But if they do split? I for one will rejoice & praise the God of Rock!

Posted by Lara | May 14, 2007 1:07 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   

They are has beens, I used to like them, but they just got so samey!! I dont care if they go!!

Posted by Matt | May 14, 2007 1:08 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescence, all over?

I thik that they'll get through it, after all, they still have Amy Lee and her amazing voice. Not only will they get through it, they'll come back even stronger!

Posted by Natasha | May 14, 2007 1:08 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescence

I couldn't believe it when I heard that Rocky AND John were both out of the group.

Evanescence has had so many chages in band members over the years, it's getting hard to keep up with it all. I mean, we've only just started to get used to seeing Tim around the place, and now we're gonna have to see two more new members.

Personally, I think Amy's just lost herself in a huge power trip. The whole band and it's image is all about "her her her". It's pathetic (Even in pictures of the band , she sticks out like a sore thumb, and the rest of the band sort of blend into the background). I used to be a huge fan of her. Now this 'obseesion' has dwindeled to nothing more than a mere attraction to their music.

I mean, how could she just up and fire John like that?! And to read that he signed a contract barring him from having any decent say in the band is just crap!

And then, to see rumours that Rocky was fired too, is just unbelievable!! They're both excellent performers and they are going to be so hard to replace. Amy must have been high on SOMETHING the day she chose to fire those guys.

And as for the wedding that supposedly happened like, right after all this firing? Is it just me, or is that event just SCREAMING publicity stunt?

Cripes. Amy, you need to respect the people who have helped "you" get Evanescence to where it is today. Without the other members (and the fans, for that matter!), you guys would probably still be doing pub gigs back in Little Rock.

Rock On

Michelle Bathgate
(A pissed off...yet still curious about what REALLY happened..."fan" in New Zealand)

Posted by Michelle Bathgate | May 14, 2007 1:11 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
What the hell is going on?!?

Why did she have to go and do such a selfish thing like that! Evanescene in my opinion have gone down-hill since they released their latest album 'The Open Door'. Its just more about her than the actual band. I think the 'Fallen' album was the best with that hard rock guitaring and awesome vocals. With this new album, you cant understand a bloody word she is saying and its all too sweet and boring. I hope they get back to their original sound and i hope they dont break up.

Posted by Ben | May 14, 2007 1:14 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
death

HOPEFULLY, amy lee will die [and be tortured] very very soon.
:)
peace homies
blud

Posted by n00b | May 14, 2007 1:16 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
death

well you sound like one of those mcr lovers and an emo fag at that how can you say that amy lee shoud be tortured. you can go and swallow a rusty knife!!!! hehehe lv ya!!!

Posted by gemrawr | May 14, 2007 2:56 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescence

yeh it\'s a shame...i\'m a fan of evanescence. they\'ve given gud music and will b missed by me and other fans

and who eva sez haley williams is a better singer is stupid because:
a) they sing in different genre it\'s like sayin angela gossow (arch enemy) is a better sing than cristna scabbia (lacuna Coil)...just doesn\'t work
b) amy lee is twice her age (bit younger maybe) so she has more experience in singin
c) they both sing with a passion and compearin them is just plain silly
d) lastly...it\'s opinion not fact

Posted by Craig aka NEWTMAN | May 14, 2007 1:19 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescence

i hope they dont spilt up
there one of my favorite bands
Amy Lee has a great voice and i hope they find other people to fill the places
but for the people thay say horrible things about them....just cos you dont like the band
i think they should be given a chance

Posted by KB | May 14, 2007 1:20 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescence

Band members come and go all the time. Some people form an emotional attachment to the bands they like, therefore the firing/ quitting of band members can take a large chuck of the fan base with them. But for people like me- who don't care who is playing as long as it rocks- this is no big deal. I can still listen to and enjoy The Open Door without wondering whatever happened to the band that created it. As for this being the end of Evanescence, I highly doubt that. The reason? I can't see Amy Lee giving up that easily. Here is a woman who clearly knows what she wants and I doubt she'll be putting an end to her band (yes, HER band) without a fight.

Posted by Sarah van Goth | May 14, 2007 1:21 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
if u wonna kno a better band then...

go here:
www.myspace.com/shewasaskingforit1

Posted by Craig aka NEWTMAN | May 14, 2007 1:23 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescence spilt

It's probably aload of lies and bollocks! I don't always believe what I read!

Posted by Hayley | May 14, 2007 1:23 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
is it all over?

Lets face it Evanescence will go on as long as Amy Lee wants it.. remember that it started out as a two peice with Ben Moody and then sesionist's played the rest. It is out of order to drop two such talented men but in my opinion long live Evanescence!

Posted by Beth Chapman | May 14, 2007 1:25 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescence Split

Whether or not Evanescence will be as big as say, the Rolling Stones, who have had a good number of members come and go over the years, or have such legend like Queen, who have Paul Rogers handling Freddy Mercury's vocals, Evanescence can continue. Face it, after Ben Boody left, thhis band became Amy Lee's band, and as long as she's in it, it will be Evanescence. Just like Guns n Roses!

Posted by Shaun Desire | May 14, 2007 1:28 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   

I think it may be all over for them, it'll be sad to see them go. But I dont think we've heard the last of Amy Lee =] xx

Posted by Greg Barrowman | May 14, 2007 1:31 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   

why are people saying amy lee is fit? she's as ugly as sin!

Posted by ash sims | May 14, 2007 1:32 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanessence

I only really like afew songs tha Evanessence has actually done and the one Amy Lee done with Seether "Broken" They were a good band, but obviously they have come to the end of an era. Evanessence will not be the same band they were without the ALL the original members. It is deffinaltey over for Evanessence as a band. Maybey John Lecompt and Rocky Gray will start their own rock band and rise above this all.
sam x

Posted by Samantha | May 14, 2007 1:33 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescence

Actually, John and Rocky have a band themselves, called Machina. It was originally supposed to be a side project, but it's now their main source of income because of the Ev firing.

http://www.machinaboard.com

Posted by Melissa | July 6, 2007 1:38 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
the split

most bands go downhill fast when members are fired/quit
this will probably happen to evanescence because they have been out of the limelight for a while.
mxxxxx

Posted by maymay | May 14, 2007 1:34 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescence

Long Live Evanescence with Hot Amy-Lee. Whoever sed they want her dead an torured i WILL find you.
You have been warned Mr. "n00b"

Posted by J/( I AM a girl!) | May 14, 2007 1:36 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescence

To be honest I think Evanescence has always be the Amy Lee show, ask most people to name member's of Evanescence apart from Amy Lee and you mostly find a blank stare in return. I think Evanescence will continue to be the Amy Lee show no matter whose on drums/guitar/bass, which is the sad reality of that "band".

Posted by Laura | May 14, 2007 1:36 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
One Girl Band.....

To be honest, as has already been posted Evanescence now is effectively Amy Lee and the rest of the 'band' is likely to be somewhat a revolving door. There is little doubt she has a great voice and a fair degree of talent but without the partnership that created a near epic first album i think she may struggle to repeat the same level of success. From interviews she doesn't really hide that she likes to be in control but that can so easily turn to megalomania. Evanescence is still a strong 'brand' but if she doesnt keep her eyes on the road she could most certainly end up another 'could of been great' road crash!

Posted by Nik | May 14, 2007 1:40 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
evenescence

if evenescence split up would anyone be bothered?they are poo!

Posted by stacey | May 14, 2007 1:40 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
evenescence

yeh well you smell of pooo!!!!!!!!!!!! you emo
fag!!!!!!!!!!!!

Posted by gemzy | May 14, 2007 3:04 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
evenescence

yeh well you smell of pooo!!!!!!!!!!!! you emo
fag!!!!!!!!!!!!

Posted by gemzy | May 14, 2007 3:04 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescence

I hope it's not the end. Amy Lee said herself that the band will get new people in and carry on touring. The only worry I have is that they may end up going down the same road as Guns N Roses and Whitesnake, great bands but who have endured constant line up changes with the lead singer being the only original member of the band and maybe one other from the bands heyday (Terry Balsamo in Evanescence, Dizzy Reed in GnR and Tommy Aldridge in Whitesnake). Hopefully, unlike GnR, we won't have to wait for eternity for any new material from Evanescence.

Posted by Ben | May 14, 2007 1:42 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   

Evanescence has always been the Amy Lee show, that's just the way it is and was. Rocky Gray, Ben Moody, and John LeCompt are all very talented musicians but like a few people have said, Evanescence are going down the Guns N Roses route and the band has all become one person.

All this said however, can you imagine Evanescence without Amy Lee?

Posted by John | May 14, 2007 1:46 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescence

nooo they can't split up :(
there is a statment on there website from amy lee saying that there still together and the concerts are'nt going to be cancelled so i suppose that is good news :)

evanescence rock!

Posted by Emma | May 14, 2007 1:49 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescence

I don't think Evanescence will split up, Amy Lee has an amazing voice and she's hot too, They'll find a new guitarist and drummer, they'll fly back

Love the mag btw started reading since 96

Posted by Christopher Boni | May 14, 2007 1:59 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
i Couldn't care a less

When willpeople take head to the fickle world of music, your bigg on day and the next your gone. Evanecance are shit anyway

Posted by Sean | May 14, 2007 2:12 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Does it Matter?

Does it particularly matter if some people have left or were thrown out. If they are gone they are gone, it's now up to Amy Lee and whoever the hell is left to continue to make music if they wanna retain any respect from fans. They wont stand by the band with unexplained or unjustified "removing" of band members forever...

Posted by Danielle | May 14, 2007 2:14 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescence

I've always kinda liked them, but not been a big fan, so i couldn't care less....it's no big loss in the world of goth/rock, the likes of Aiden and Cradle of Filth are miles better anyway!! But I do think that Amy Lee should go solo, because she is a great singer.

Posted by Lewis | May 14, 2007 2:17 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescence about fucking time

I am glad that they have split to be fair i thought that they were overated and i wouldn't actually call them Rock they were far from heavy.
To be honest i would have said that they were over yonks ago cos they certainly have not released anything of interest lately, Unfortunately (for them) there is to much stiff competition around now and new bands piss all over shit like them.

Phew rant over but P.S guys don't let a prissy girl like Amy Lee tell you what you can and can't do she might have a good voice and a pretty face but the band wouldnt have been the band without the dudes who could play the instruments front men/women get to much of the credit these days give the other members some slack!!!

xx

Posted by Gemma | May 14, 2007 2:21 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
evanescence

i love evanescence and have all there sogs and cd's. i think amy lee is a wicked singer and hope they do not split.
i love most of her songs and the words to thm mean things to me and my life.
i allways listen to there songs and all ways will.

long live evaanescence.

Posted by Heather Burman | May 14, 2007 2:21 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
evanescence

i don't know and don't care anymore about them evanesence to me is dead...i liked 'em back with all the original members!! don't try to rebuild something that's long gone i think!
the old material rocks but i'm not so keen on open door....i couldn't careless if they split it makes more room in kerrang mag for bands that are going somewhere.
x

Posted by patricia | May 14, 2007 2:25 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
helo0o0o saraa!!

Helo0o0o Sarah!!
Dis lesson iz bullshyt!! :D:D
Owa yo0o0o??
Wb lurvee frm meee (hev!!)
xxxxxxXXXXXXXXXXxxxxxxxx

Posted by xx-Hevman-xx | May 14, 2007 2:28 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
evenesence

i love dem , lets face it the singer makes the band and even if they have been fired unfairly they can be easily replaced its not like their the only people in the world who can play guitar and drums, maybe she replaced dem for better models??? anyhoos dey wont split coz shes a strong woman who knows what shes doing.
xx

Posted by stacey | May 14, 2007 2:28 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
helo0o0o saraa!!

Helo0o0o Sarah!!
Dis lesson iz bullshyt!! :D:D
Owa yo0o0o??
Wb lurvee frm meee (hev!!)
xxxxxxXXXXXXXXXXxxxxxxxx

Posted by xx-Hevman-xx | May 14, 2007 2:30 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
long live evanescence

I couldn't believe it when I heard that 2 band members had gone. I was so shocked but I have to say Amy Lee will pull through this and make more music to put the rest of the bands out there to shame. I am sure of it I mean I( wouldn't take the time to write this if I wasn't sure would I? No! If they split it would be such a shame as they are they play the best music I can find! Long Live Evanescence! luv Anna xx


Posted by Anna | May 14, 2007 2:32 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   

I couldn't believe it when I heard that 2 band members had gone. I was so shocked but I have to say Amy Lee will pull through this and make more music to put the rest of the bands out there to shame. I am sure of it I mean I( wouldn't take the time to write this if I wasn't sure would I? No! If they split it would be such a shame as they are they play the best music I can find! Long Live Evanescence! luv Anna xx

Posted by O0O0OHH | May 14, 2007 2:32 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   

I couldn't believe it when I heard that 2 band members had gone. I was so shocked but I have to say Amy Lee will pull through this and make more music to put the rest of the bands out there to shame. I am sure of it I mean I( wouldn't take the time to write this if I wasn't sure would I? No! If they split it would be such a shame as they are they play the best music I can find! Long Live Evanescence! xx

Posted by O0O0OHH | May 14, 2007 2:33 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
evanescence

Personally i don't think Amy Lee would have fired the both of them. she may have fired the one but would have had valid reason if she was given a chance. Amy cares too much about her music carreer AND her band to throw it all away over nothing. i hope it all works out because Evanescence rock and it would be awful to lose them.

Posted by Peeg | May 14, 2007 2:39 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescence

Evanescence will never be over until Amy Lee leaves, its because people only know Evanescence as being Amy Lee, so it wont be hard for them to find another guitarist

Posted by Rich | May 14, 2007 2:43 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
At least the lawyers'll do well

Amy 'Oh, oh look at me, look how great i am, look at meeee, LOOK AT ME' Lee, when exactly is she going to get over herself. Christ, as if her egotistical power trip wasn't bad enough last time, this just takes the piss.
This is exactly the reason rock music is going to shit. The front dudes/chicks go on a power trip, convince themselves that they don't need anyone except those cute little voices in their head, and hey presto, another rock band confined to the vault of failed attempts at making a statement.
Oh well, at the end of the day, no-one reeeaaaally listened to the band, they just thought Amy Lee looked good in a corset...to be fair, she does.
My thoughts and prayers are with the poor therapist she married, at least he won't be afraid to cry.

Much love Kerrang x

Posted by Matty | May 14, 2007 2:43 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescence

Im not the biggest fan of Evanescence to be honest but the way i see it is if amy thinks firing rocky and john is best for the band then they must have some type of plan of action otherwise its just a stupid egotistical thing to do.

But to be honest people being fired or quitting bands hasn't meant the end of bands in the past so i don't see why it should be this time.

http://www.myspace.com/jimbob34

Posted by James Lancaster | May 14, 2007 2:45 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Amy Lee the solo pianist?

Amy Lee would do well as a soloest singing to her piano arrangements. some of the ballards Evanescence have recored are amazing! and it would be easier to acciate her voice!
Anyway if they better not split compleatly before Download! they're one of the main reasons I'm going this year!!!

Posted by Florence | May 14, 2007 2:45 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   

well, after Ryan Dunn, I think that was his name *no good at remembering names*, left the band it was pretty obvious that Evanescence will go down sooner or later.
Amy Lee is really silly to think that she can do what ever she wants to whom ever she wants and that the fans will stand behind her. I mean now that it's pretty obvious how she treats other ppl who will want to play in her band? And I doubt that the fans will accept that either, well at least I won't.

Loves

Posted by Intoccabile | May 14, 2007 2:57 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescence

stig_guitar@hotmail.co.uk

I think Amy Lee should go solo, i feel as though it was 'the Amy Lee show' from the start, she was always the centre of attention in magazine articles and on t.v. that's probably the reason why the guys quit, they couldn't bear to be in the shadows any longer and felt that their talents could be used elswhere. i don't think there is anybody else who can put up with her ego and the only person that can is Amy herself.

Posted by Steve Morris | May 14, 2007 2:58 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
NO

I hate evanescence.
I also love emos though.
All emo girls are really fit.
When i date an emo girl, i make her feel better about herself so that she will stop hurting herself.

I think emos are lush mate.
So i hate the people that say they hate them!


I hate scenes because i hate vain people!

I like the people who are suicidal because i like to know i have saved a life.

Posted by Italian_Stalion | May 14, 2007 2:59 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
call me when you're solo

am i the only one to wonder why it matters if people are leaving Evanescence. Simply put, it doesnt.
Evanescence has always been the Amy Lee show, (songs like my immortal prove this) so she might as well go solo.
this isnt a criticism, im a fan of Evanescence, but i dont know why she keeps the band going when its plainly just her with people supporting her.
just go solo, make some new songs, sell records and play gigs, nuff said.

p.s. Kerrang rock!!!!!
xxxx

Posted by stuart | May 14, 2007 3:02 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
I don't get it

In all honesty I don't really understand why there is so much noise revolving this issue. Not because I don't like this band, but because it sounds all so useless to me. After all Evanescence now is the Amy Lee show, she is the only founder and core member of the band and calls the shots as to what to do with it and that includes hiring and firing sidemen. Gray and LeCompt are hired guns that came on board after the recording of Fallen and the need to send a band that was essentially a duo on the road. If there was ever a moment to question the band's future was when Ben Moody, apparently an equal to Amy Lee, got fired not now that two sidemen are crying because they don't have a steady check for their bills. The only thing that can stop this band from carrying on is the inevitable change of fashions and the lack of interest in it from the crowds.

Posted by Syl | May 14, 2007 3:02 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Italian_Stalion

This is for Italian Stalion.

Hu do u finnk u are?
Im scene n quite proud.
Ye we r vain but that is coz we can be so get lost.

Emos suck coz they dnt appreciate there lives which is annoyin.
also, talkin depressed annoys me

Posted by Punjabi_MC | May 14, 2007 3:03 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
To the scene girl

that scene girl that admits she is vain can just get lost.

emos are cool so i dont know why people get annoyed by them

they have problems in their lives that they want help with and im happy to help so just go away sceney.

Posted by Italian_Stalion | May 14, 2007 3:05 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Italian_Stalion

u sound like a spak mate. Italian stalion wat kinda name is that?
ye i cant believe ppl like u actually take emos seriously

ppl like all have theirown problems right but they keep that to the ppl who care bout them and sort it out by themselves.

those kindsa ppl get their problems sorted rite bcoz they aint sittin around just lookin for attention

Posted by Punjabi_MC | May 14, 2007 3:08 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
whatever

whatever ok? you are scene so you are gay. you just dont take anyones feelings into consideration but i like to help turn emos lives around alright?

what kind of name is Punjabi MC anyway? so dont take the piss out of my screen name!!!!

Posted by Italian_Stalion | May 14, 2007 3:13 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
i love emos

look 'scene girl'
emos are such amazing people so you can fuck off.
i hate you scene kids who think your well cool and fit
WELL YOUR NOT
your mums is though.
bare fit

ps.
i hate you.
pss.
go die.
pss.
EMOS RULE!

Posted by shitonyourmum | May 14, 2007 3:15 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
oi nugnugs

wats rong wiv da name punjabi?
mi nan iz calld punjabi dere iz nufin rong wiv dat.
ennit bruv.
go fuk my dad u shitty shit.
ill batta u, if u talk bout mi nana agen ennit.
iiiiite.

Posted by paki_no1 | May 14, 2007 3:16 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
emos are

NANG.

Posted by i love emos | May 14, 2007 3:18 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
punjaaaaaaaaaab

get lost you fakko. i actually hate people like you. Yes i hate your nans name. your name is an old naan bread. who shouldn't be able to come out of her pitta bread.

Posted by Italian_Stalion | May 14, 2007 3:19 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescence OVER?!

Please tell me they're NOT over!
Seriously, Evanescence are just amazing!
They can't be over!
And one more thing ...

EMOS ARE AMAZING!
Scene kids are just fucked up in the head!

Posted by Rachel Kennedy | May 14, 2007 3:21 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
wagwan

wagwan G's
wats gwarnin?

i iz like well hard black man ennit.
i have a well big 10 inch dick
i want your nan to suck it
ive seen her pitta bread G.
its all saggy and wrinkley ennit
her pussy is bald.


with no fillings innnit
just a bit of corination chickwaan

Posted by G_man | May 14, 2007 3:22 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
G's

iiiiite agen
i forget to add
do you fart first thing in the morninng?

Posted by G_man | May 14, 2007 3:23 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
It's All Bitter Sweet!

ok, take five mins and look back at the problems Amy Lee has accually been through in her life, accually, take 10 mins! She has over come so much throughout the years, this isnt the first time band members has left and to be quite frank, it may not be the last. We need to move on and support Amy all the way! She still plans to tour with new musicians so it wont be the last we hear from the band. You can say whatever you like to her, say she's a bad singer and in the wrong by firing john from the band but we all need to understand, Amy is one tough nut, she's come out on top many times, going from bad situations to a multi-platinum album! Whats more is that she knows whats best for the band, so rock on Amy!

Posted by Connor Lalitte | May 14, 2007 3:23 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
SAM LOWTHER

is a pussy i hate her

Posted by ihateher | May 14, 2007 3:23 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescence

I saw on the website that shes gonna get a new drummer n tht so hpefully they'll still be together

Posted by sarah | May 14, 2007 3:25 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
who

IS CALLED RACHEL KENNEDY.

Posted by OI | May 14, 2007 3:25 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
i

love sam really (L)

Posted by im sorry | May 14, 2007 3:26 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
ALICE DARBY

SUCKS MY PUSSY

TRIM YOUR TWAT MATE
=]

Posted by pussy_hole | May 14, 2007 3:27 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescence

Hey people.This is about Evanescence, not emo or scene people.Yes emos ae the best, ever and scene people are stuck up there own arse. So I think Amy Lee's voice is way better then Hailey Williams.I do like Paramore but Amy Lee is like wow!

Posted by Hannah | May 14, 2007 3:31 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
fuk dat!!!

evenescence cant be over because dey neva started in da 1st place they r fukin SHIT m8
!!!!!!

Posted by jenna hunter | May 14, 2007 3:31 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
dude

dude amy lee is good looking but a bad singer anyways why are thay leaving?

Posted by Ben Smith | May 14, 2007 3:33 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
evanescence

Amy lee is getting too full of herself. but she has a BRILLIANT voice :)

Posted by Ami | May 14, 2007 3:37 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   

evanescence isnt over it never started its always been about Amy Lee even if they all split it wouldnt be any differennt because she takes all the credit anyway

Posted by Mr Blobby | May 14, 2007 3:45 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
ALL OVER!?

Evanescene all over?
Didn't know they were still a band I thought it was Amy Lee and others.
Lets hope this is the end and they can be replaced at Download by a band people will actually want to see... Prefurably give Killswitch a longer set. Amy Lee can sing but doesn't she know it, After about one song I feel a great urge to strangle her.

Posted by Jennifer Heathcote | May 14, 2007 3:46 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
...

Thats right I can't spell Evanescence

Posted by Jennifer Heathcote | May 14, 2007 3:48 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
evanescence and paramore

ok, Evanescence have gone down hill. ther old stuff was amazing but now i can't bare to listen to it as it makes my ears bleed! Its's almost like listening to Charlotte fuckin' Church... i said almost..

and also, wot the fuck is wrong with you people who say Hayley Williams can't sing!?! I've herd some amazing voices as my mum owns a dancing school (singing lessons DUH) and shows and bands in general. plus my grandad dragged me to some opera but that not the point... SHES FUCKING AWESOME! she gets to such high notes it makes Mika sound like Pavrotti!!

So leave it out yeah.

Posted by Elli | May 14, 2007 3:49 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
evanescence.

I think evanescence arent going to be over they're just no going to sound as amazing as they are now. Amy Lee has an amazing voice and with the guitars and drums in the background it makes an wicked sound. No-one can copy or attempt to make the same sound that evanescence makes today. And Yes Paramore are cool but come on Amy Lee's voice is way better. And didn't one of the guitarists leave or sumthing already? Did that stop Evanescence? No. So why should they give it up now?

Posted by Latoya | May 14, 2007 3:51 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   

Amy Lee and Hayley Williams both hav good voices, there just different

Nahhhhhhh!

Posted by nah | May 14, 2007 3:54 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescence..

Evanescence have gone downhill since the release of 'The Open Door'. Don't get me wrong I used to be a big fan but they just havn't got it anymore. Something like this was just waiting to happen!
Amy Lee has got a wicked voice though, although sometimes it resembles a wailing cat =D

Posted by Maddy | May 14, 2007 3:55 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
evanescence

I am a HUGE fan of evanescence and amy has stated that Evanescence will live on! Amy's sister Lori Lee said that John and Rocky were both going to quit the band anyway to pursue their other band Machina so amy fired john so that the tour wasnt goping to be uncomfortable! And Rocky left because John is his best friend. Amy must already have found replacments because she also said that none of the tour dates will be changed!!!

Love jack :]]]

Also if you dont like Evanescence then why bother coming here and posting?

Posted by Evanescence will live | May 14, 2007 3:56 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanesesnce

well to be honest i think its a good thing and evanesence should deserve the radio play and Tv play becuase theyre new album is shite me and my freind listened to it all the way through and later tht day i was humming one of the songs and my mates was singing different lyrics to one of the other lithium i think and well they sound the same she has just used melodies from other songs on the album as vocal melodies for another utter crap if i should say so. now im not saying she isnt a good singer but the open door was awfull. also they are all up themselves with this new album and realy dont deserve the record sales.think of some amazing bands with female singers that dnt get any radio play like Within Temptation as a start who have been around alot longer and musically are so much better now im only 16 and im a newbie to alternative music, 14 i got into it and i knew straight away thet Within temptation were the better band in all aspects even though i was brought up wid evanessence on the radio. also yes i know theyre different geners but Light this city and Amzing band from america they just not getting radio play.and finally one of the best around at the moment are Deadlock with Sabine Weniger
who has the most angelic amazing voice around and dear i say it better tham Cristina Scabbia and has realy made Deadlock sound like a band with a great mix of male and feamle vocals.
so i have to say thank you Evanesence for getting rid of your guitarist cause now u can split and make way for some fucking talented bands who are a band and not just a frontwoman and a bunch of guys who wear balck in the background.

Posted by Jordan Doyle | May 14, 2007 3:57 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescence

Evanescence seem to always have difficulties in keeping band members. Even though I love evanescence to peices, I dont think that the band is going to last, everyone is starting to think that Amy Lee is just moaning about how much her life is bad, Evanescence has gone down hill! Fallen and Origin had depth and meaning to the lyrics and you had to look at the metaphorical refrences. With Open the Door the meanings are staring back at you. With the last band member that left, it was due to creative diffrences. Did Amy fire him too? Or was he the one that left?

Posted by Jennifer | May 14, 2007 3:58 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
evanescence

Well i seriously think that with two members leaving they will really struggle to get over it. I also think that if they do manage to get someone else in that it will be hard for them to settle in very quickly at all. Therefore it wouldn't surprise me if they decide to pull out of download. However there are plenty of similar bands that fans can get into and also that could replace them if they do pull out.

Posted by dave sunley | May 14, 2007 4:02 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescence

Sure.. Evanescence are a good band vocals and instrument wise but they never had the back ground that is team work. The one thing to keep a band "a band". Sure Amy Lee is i'm sure a very nice person but from fan perspective it's her alone and just a few random musicians, she is a little to indepedent to be one of a band, i mean when i first heard of evanescence i thought it was her alone. Thats not the kind of interpretation a fan should have and the musician should give out. I'm sure Amy Lee will find suitable replacements but she will have to loose some of her independence before they loose more members and even their careers. Evanescence should stand strong aslong as Amy comes down off her high horse a little.

Posted by Jonny D. | May 14, 2007 4:05 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescence

To be honest, I don't think that if they did carry on, they wouldn't be Evanescence. The line-up has changd so much that there's hardly any founding members left. Amy Lee has an amazing voice, and it is stupid to waste it on a band where members are coming and going every few months. She should do her own solo project. Evanescence had its time, and now that time has passed. Evanescence should quit now while they can still be remembered for their amazing music rather than quarrelling over who's in the band and who isnt.

Posted by Dawn | May 14, 2007 4:06 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescence

i meant lose** << ... X_X

Posted by Jonny D. | May 14, 2007 4:07 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
evenescence

maybe they can maybe they can't, the only ones who can tell you if they are going down the pan are evenscence themselves,........

Posted by giselle | May 14, 2007 4:09 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Lets Face It...

Lets face it... with bands like Paramore breaking through it just doesn't cut it to be a female lead singer any more!

Times change and people need more. But was it really the best idea to axe members of the band?

I guess the plan is to replace them with new members but Amy Lee needs to remember that people don't just like bands for the frontman/singer!

As much as I like her I think she needs to make then band about the music... not her.

Posted by Elly | May 14, 2007 4:09 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescence

I think Evanescence are the best band ever!!! They arent gonna end their new album rocks and why would amy fire a member without a good reson 2 weeks before thir next gig! He obviously deserved it or something!

love jack :]]]

Posted by Jack | May 14, 2007 4:09 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
No way

I dont think there over, they have been trough stuff like this before with band memebers leaving. Why should it be diffrent now? The can easy be re-placed, no matter who is in the band Evanescence are still going to produce awesome music. Maybe its a good thing becasue people who are not going to put an effort in the band are not worth being in there. Amy-Lees voice is amazing and it shouldent go to waste just because of people leaving the band.

Posted by Amy | May 14, 2007 4:09 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescence

I think Evanescence was over along time ago... Mainly when they stepped into the pop world. They have only done one good song and that was "Bring me to life", and they had to have 12 stones front man Paul McCoy to sing in it aswell. They are an "ok" band but there are many other better bands around with female singers such as Lacuna coil, Paramore, Within temptation, flyleaf and many more... Evanescence should let bands like them get back into the headlines. If Evanescence are to continue, then i think they should step out of the pop life and do better and more rock/goth songs!

Posted by Ryan | May 14, 2007 4:10 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   

Right,
considering that Evanescence has only one of it's original members left from the start, and now the newens are getting sacked. I wouldn't think be completely suprised if they did split now.
But tbh, i can't say i'd be fully dissappointed.
:)

Posted by Joe | May 14, 2007 4:16 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescence

To be honest, I don't think it is 'all over' for Evanescence at all, Amy Lee will continue fighting for the band as she has done sinse the age of fourteen. The memberlist has changed many times before, so I'm sure they will pull through once again. Note to the people who say Amy Lee is full of herself, she really isnt, I met her last year in London, and she's certainly not big headed or stuck up in any way, shape, or form. This has been her dream sinse being a little girl, I'm sure she knows whats best, what you have to remember, is just because they are famous, doesn't mean they aren't going to disagree and argue, would you like to spend 24 hours a day, almost 7 days a week, with someone who you dont get along with? Sometimes you have to make sacrifices, and replacing band members is one of them. Long live Evanescence xxx

Posted by Rebecca | May 14, 2007 4:16 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
evenescence/amy lee

Bassically i think that even before 'The Open Door' was releasd, Evenescence wasn't Evenescence anymore, it was 'Amy Lee and the Others', and frankly i think Amy Lee is going down the same route as Axl Rose did with Gn'R.
Kerrang! magazine even makes it clear in captions and reviews for Evenescence, that the contrast between the recently asigned members is obvious, where, lets face it, the other members arnt exactly stunning.
That says to me that they were chosen because they can play the songs and make Amy Lee better.
And despite being the frontwoman, there shouldnt be such vast spaces between the other members and Amy Lee when on stage, such as their London show last year. Kerrang! (issue 1138) reviewed this and mentioned this was their biggest flaw, where on stage "she over-shadows her band mates entirely" and also that the other members look "nothing more than a backing band".
I'm not particually bothered by the split, but all i'll say now is that Amy should have started a solo preject when Evenescence fell apart the first time, because it's meaningless to carry on the band name when its not Evenescence anymore.

Owen Palmer, Hemel Hempstead

Posted by Owen Palmer | May 14, 2007 4:17 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
On-Going.....

There seems to be a number of annoying on-going trend with bands nowadays. They either swap members...have "side-projects" (i.e. get-out clauses) or their members leave and get replaced over and over again....

You expect this sort of thing from the pop industry, like the sugababes *hitting myself for knowing that right now*, but the rock world should be setting an example.

I think bands like Evanescence should call it a day.....they've had their run and they are only going to announce that they're fininshed in a few months anyway after flagging sales and rubbish gig reveiews.....

Stay in the bad or don't bother.

Posted by Lyzsi Sinclair | May 14, 2007 4:20 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescence

Evanescence are a great band and there is no point comparing them to lacuna coil,mcr, paramore, etc coz all bands a different. I know amy lee is full of her self but so what. she is Evanescence! i guess everyone has their own opinion.
all bands end someday. and i guess it looks like amy lee is going down the same road as sonny moore.

Posted by rockonmate | May 14, 2007 4:23 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescene

I cannot see this being the end of Evanescence. As time goes on it seems to me that the band is becoming more and more built around Amy Lee and her image. Even the departure of Ben Moody after "Fallen" hasn't stopped the release and success of "The Open Door".

I can only see the band splitting if Amy herself leaves she is the drive, the image and most importantly the voice behind Evanescence.

Posted by Sam Pointer | May 14, 2007 4:23 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescence

I think that Evanescence are the best female fronted band around and will continue to be in years to come! But I think if amy has made a choise then I agree! If its for the best interest of the band that john was fired then I suport it! People who are saying that its just amy and the others, you're partly right because hse is THE original member and affectivly it is HER band but I see what you are saying sometimes but I dont think she truly intends to over shadow her other band mates!

Posted by Jack Iverson | May 14, 2007 4:26 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   

Evanescence is not over! they have come through much worse than this and they have always managed to survive. For example when Ben Moody left they managed to find a replacement quickly and carry on with their tour. Although Evanescence is not going to be the same it is going to be a new chapter for them and they will definitely come back stronger than ever.

Posted by rebecca | May 14, 2007 4:28 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
If I were to CARE.. this is what I'd say.

Sounds like another case of a lead singer getting "too big" for their band.. When in fact it is just their ego that has grown.
I am apathetic towards the split of a band that I never really cared for due to the radio saturation and "poppiness" of their records.
I think they were on track in the style that they wanted to create, but honestly i heard no REAL musicianship or clear crisp vocals. For female singers.. unless you are Arch Enemy, that is a must.
Amy Lee is no Sarah Jezebel Deva.. If you don't know who that is.. look it up.
My 2 cents.

Posted by Angela | May 14, 2007 4:29 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescence

I like their music but really, who cares who plays in evanescence apart from Amy Lee. Shes the voice, face and writer of evanescence and as long as she doesn't quit then evanesence will always be around. Basically Her with a back in group any way. Just being honest folks. Their new album should of been beter with all honestly but they still rock!

Posted by Alex King | May 14, 2007 4:30 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescence "Fired" Band Members

i think evanescence are an alright band... not big on them but i think Amy Lee will just get more band members. Shes the main focus in the band anyways and gains most of the cred so people wont be to bothered bout the "firings" im not.... i think she will continue to try and keep her reputation before quitting or go solo

curt jackson - kerrang everyweek reader

Posted by Curtis Jackson | May 14, 2007 4:31 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescence

Well...
it's too bad about that..they have gone through a few band member changes and obviously have come back..I don't think it is the end because they are doing too good..but if you look at Nirvana,they were at their peek when Kurt died
so yeah...I hope it's not over 'cause I kinda love them...

Posted by Brittany | May 14, 2007 4:33 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescence, or Amy Lee?

Only one of the original members of Evanescence is remaining, and of course, that's Amy Lee.
Evanescence always seems to have been about Amy and her image.
And to prove my point, if you go up to some of the fans at an Evanescence gig and ask them the names of the other band members, i'm sure many would know none other than Amy.
Now despite that i do not agree with lead singers being the main focus of the band, i still do like Evanescence's music, and i went to go see them live last year.
And i was very dissapointed when i did. They didn't sound good live, especially Amy's voice, and again, it felt like it was all about Amy. The rest of the band were standing in black, and there she was prancing about on stage in a huge bright pink skirt.
It saddens me that with a band as musically gifted as Evanescence, an ego like Amy's has to split up the band.
I used to be a fan.
Now, i've lost all hope for them.

Alicia
xxx

Posted by Alicia Turner | May 14, 2007 4:33 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
what the bloody hell

wtf is bloody wrong with her as an avid fan of the band ive gott say im pretty bloody shocked, i mean rocky and john bloody make the band, and soon if she keeps ridding members of the band in unexplained circumstances she aint gonna get very faar with that reputation is she?

Posted by areena | May 14, 2007 4:36 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   

i love evanescence and i would be totally ruined if they split i think amy's voice is so amazing but maybe she should work on being a band more than a soloist but i still don't think any one should have the right to shit talk about them cos i would love to hear all the fuckers sing you say she can't sing.who ever doesn't like evanescence then you are toally fucked up!and while i'm on the subject who ever says MCR are shit i know you are fucked up cos they are the most amazing band next to evanescence and if you don't like them or evanescence then keep it to your self cos to be honest i don't give a shit what you think of them unless you think there good then i care :D

Posted by hannah | May 14, 2007 4:43 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
evenescance

I actually think Evenesances latest album wasnt worth all the hype it got. Sure it was a good album but compared to Fallen it wasnt so great. Also, with Within Temptation coming to the UK, along with bands such as Lacuna Coil, I dont think Evenescance will be lasting much longer if they keep firing members. Only one origional member of Evenescance remains - Amy Lee. I thik theyre heading on a downwards spiral; which is unfortunate as they really are a good band. xxxx.

Posted by Helena Daly | May 14, 2007 4:46 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
"I was fired for no good reason"

Evanescence-they're totally amazing, they've got me through some of the hardest part of my lives. And God, can Amy Lee sing? She's brilliant; one of the best female singers I've heard. Yep, they're amazing. Totally.

Posted by Ashli | May 14, 2007 4:47 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   

Scene kids are losers in sorry but they are took stuck up there own ass .
Emo kids are cool , well fitt and careing

evanescence is annoying they only have like 2 good songs

Posted by Sweetly Numb | May 14, 2007 4:48 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescence: is it over?

Amy Lee is like marmite; you either love her or hate her. But no one can deny she's the reason as to why Evanescence is successful. Lee has co - written every single track by Evanescence (dating back to 98 when the first Evanescence EPs were released) she's always had input. When Moody split she no longer needed to share duties with the other members, Evanescence became hers. Many people say a band is made up of many people, Evanescence isn’t. Evanescence IS Amy Lee. There’s a reason she alone is on all the covers, why people care about aspects of her life? Amy Lee doesn’t care what you think about her because she doesn’t need to. She's gotten this far doing it her way, and that’s more than a successful way.

Posted by Ian Henson | May 14, 2007 4:49 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Sweet Amy??

it seems to me that Evanescence has been dominated by Amy and nobody else really had a say.
Honestly, I dont think Amy Lee is a nice person, why else would so many members have left and been fired!

Posted by Lauren | May 14, 2007 4:49 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
thats a bit of a dent in them

well yeah i think tis proberly true wat they sed cause she is the only founding member of the band left ( i think) and prevoius members like moody have sed things simalar like we havnt seen eye to eye which tis why he walked . anyway without major parts of the band it may be hard to carry on

x

Posted by dave watkins | May 14, 2007 4:50 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescence - Girl Power!

Oh My Fucking God! Amy Lee being egotistical!? I dont think so! To be fair...it is Amy Lee's band so IF John and Rocky were fired I'm sure it must have been for a good reason. Surely Amy Lee would go solo if the band did split? And be very successful. Either that or she should get Ben Moody back! He was a better guitarist...and friend!

Posted by Kara-Marie | May 14, 2007 4:51 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
evanescence

amy lee is a stuck up whore who has an ego larger than a house, she cant sing, only had i decent song and the second album was just a peice of crap.

Posted by ollie pay | May 14, 2007 4:54 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescence: is it over?

Thank god.
I don't like Evanescence, and to hear they could be on a downward fall makes me very happy.
No need to fire everyone just to get in the spolight, even more so than you are.
xxx

Posted by Kerry | May 14, 2007 4:57 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescence

They'll be fine, they coped well with the loss of Moody a few years back didn't they?

Posted by Dan | May 14, 2007 4:58 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Amy the diva

if them being fired is true then she is turning into one hell of a diva, it seems that once a band has one person who can fire the rest its no longer a band, i think she sees them as her backing band that can be disposed of when she likes, but who cares there are much better bands out there...xox

Posted by Karima | May 14, 2007 5:00 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Yeah right Evanescence are over!

Everyone knows that Amy Lee is going to continue Evanescence with new members -after all, she's the only member that anyone can name! The rest of the band are just basically people in the background that never get coverage in stories, apart from Ben Moody before he left. I had never heard of John and Rocky before this story and I think that Amy Lee really needs to pull herself together and start treating Evanescence as a band rather than a solo act.

Posted by Laura | May 14, 2007 5:02 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
This Sucks

This sucks, i'm going to download to basically see Evanescence, i just hope they survive because after the loss of former guitarist Ben Moody it took them a while to reform, lets just hope they dont cancel on download now huh?

I am also shocked that Amy Lee would just call him up and fire him like that, i always thought she would have more respect than that, or is fame finally getting to her?

Posted by Amiee-Louise | May 14, 2007 5:03 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescence!!

they'll just go on with new bandmebers (I hope). there just gread and there verry big in Europ they won't give tat up Amy Lee will not do that!!!

Posted by yara | May 14, 2007 5:08 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Amy is Evanescence

I refuse to believe Amy fired them! She said in an official statement that they chose to leave. Amy has brought Evanescence through some tough times but there're still going strong! She said:
"Evanescence is something I have loved and nurtured since I was fourteen, and I will continue to protect and fight for it as I always have."
She is a highly talented musician. Other members have left in the past but that never stopped her.
ROCK ON AMY! \m/

Posted by Charlie Valletta | May 14, 2007 5:10 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   

btw everyone within temptation are fucking shit they're are just a crap wanna be evanescence and she really can't sing compared to amy so get used to the fact tht evanescence are totaly emensly ace and will live forever

Posted by hannah | May 14, 2007 5:11 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescense

Evanescense will probably do fine without Rocky and John, which is actually really unfair because Amy Lee's band never get any recognition. Amy Lee could change her whole band line up and probably no one would even notice because she's the face of the band.

Posted by Harriet | May 14, 2007 5:12 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanesence

Evanescence are a good band but I think there time is up. I didn't really think there new stuff was as good anyway. Amy Lee is a brilliant vocalist and should continue singing but I think Evanescence should stop here.

Posted by Sián.M | May 14, 2007 5:17 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   

I think it's really sad, how it all sums up again. Amy the evil one, the others the poor ones...anyways...the only ones who are really suffering under that whole lot of s*** are fans (like me)...at least, if this means that they're going to quit completely next.
At the moment it looks as though they won't last that long any more.
It's the second time, that Amy has fired (or whatever) band memebers...how long will she do it? She destroys everything, in my opinion. If I REALLY am a band, than I don't fire people just because I don't like their nose or whatever...
That leads to the other problem: Did she have any reasons? No one said anything officially, so from where do we know, that LeCompte and Grey are telling the entire trouth?
As far as no one speaks officially I wouldn't throw my hand in fire, blaming anyone.

Fact is, it's shit. Fans are the real victims of that. As long as none of the "higher people" notices that, nothing will change.

Amen.^^

Posted by Mio | May 14, 2007 5:21 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   

so what people in band get fired-and replace-no big fuss-the only fuss really is if a vocalist goes cause then they never sound the same

Posted by Ben | May 14, 2007 5:22 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   

dark_fairy611@hotmail.co.uk
add meeee pweeeeeeeeese!!!
btw guys EMOS RULE and scene kids are gay so get used to it and whoever wants to argue bout it take it to your grave cos dnt bother i aint listening
i'm emo iand i slit so whocares emos are cool and not all emos slit and the ones that do obviosly have a really hard life like me and i don't want to sound ungratefull but i do have a shit life and i know others are worse off than me butthey just choose to deal with it differently and everyone has there own opinions oh and i'm half goth to and i think everyones agrees with me here when i say EMO BOYS ARE SOOOOOOOO FIT i love snake bites on an emo guy its so shmexc and they loook cool on girls to =D and not all emos are depressed some are cool like me jokes lol but don't steroe type people from what you've heard!!!!
and everyone don't forget add me pweeeeeeeeeese ADD ME WOOOOOO
dark_fairy611@hotmail.co.uk

Posted by hannah | May 14, 2007 5:23 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   

no way is this the end of Evanescence, this is not the first time there has been a line-up change and it most probably won't be the last. i don't know if they really were fired and to be honest i don't care, everyone knows the band is all about miss (or is it mrs now?) Amy Lee.

P.S. Amy Lee and Hayley Williams are both amazing vocalists and both front amazing bands and are both amazingly beautiful =] x

Posted by danielle clarke | May 14, 2007 5:23 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply
Name:
Email address:
Website:
 
   
Evanescence:over or not

i'm in two minds about all of this. i love evanescence and amy lee so much, i've been a fan since 2003 but rocky and john getting fired/quitting makes me think that this maybe the end of the band as they've been through a few member changes. amy shouldnt fired anyone at all because the band has been at an all time high lately so i dont know what to believe. i hope they don't quit as i love the band but i dont like amy lee that much and never have.

Posted by Death_Bed_Confession | May 14, 2007 5:30 PM | Reply to this
Don't reply